Wind Farm Fear

101 unbelievable wind turbine health scares

Addendum, May 15: the list can be downloaded directly, in its most recent version, by clicking here – currently at 114 and still growing!

Professor Simon Chapman and his team at the University of Sydney have reached triple figures with their list of health problems alleged to be caused by wind farms.

Entitled “Is there anything not caused by wind farms?“, the document describes itself as “a list of diseases, symptoms and aberrant behaviours in humans and animals said to be caused by wind turbines.”

Here are some particular eyebrow-raisers:

  • “Air quality damage”: “… the proposed wind farm would ruin the pristine beauty of the area, damage air quality and increase noise levels.” [Presumably this air quality problem is related to fan death?]
  • Sheep: “…very sensitive to noise and to disturbance. This will impact their ability to go where they’re used to going” [Are they having trouble “going”? Can you get laxatives for sheep?]
  • Goats, unexplained mass deaths “In New Zealand, 400 goats dropped dead.” [Are we quite sure it wasn’t the Men Who Stare at Goats doing training?]
  • Dairy cows shocked through milking machines (because of “stray or tingle voltage”) [stray voltage escaping into the ground… does this mean rubber boots are needed? Presumably the danger exists around any electric wiring with an earth lead?]
  • Weight gain and Weight loss [Both are listed. Does that mean they cancel out? Or do they affect different areas of the body simultaneously?]
  • Earthworms leave the soil near wind turbines “seagulls no longer follow the plough in areas near wind turbines. It has been suggested that the seagulls have learned that the worms have all been driven away and that in that area the farmer’s plough will not bring breakfast to the surface. They must go elsewhere for their food.” Suggestion is this effect might be as wide as 18km radius from a turbine.
  • Deaths, yes, many deaths “These extensive studies report numerous serious illnesses and, yes, many deaths, mainly from unusual cancers.” [I don’t propose anyone should laugh at people dying of cancer, but as with many claims made, we should question such sensationalist, and trivialising, attribution for such a horrible disease]
Wind Farm Fear
Image from the animation “Wind Energy, myths and facts” (click to view)

The document can be downloaded here, and includes references to where each of the various and unusual claims are being made. Warning: reading it may cause certain symptoms too!

Dr Chapman has an open invite for people who are aware of any extra claims, please send them to him (details in the document) – or leave as a comment, with a link to the source, at the bottom of this post, and we’ll forward them on to him, whether or not you think they are a serious concern…

16 thoughts on “101 unbelievable wind turbine health scares

  1. Some of these claims are obviously far-fetched and/or tongue-in-cheek, however the dismissive and cavalier comments of Courtice demonstrate the actual lack of care and concern for turbine-induced health issues.

    If you publish “101 things caused by wind turbines” you should also publish the list of over 800 issues claimed to be caused by Global Warming.
    Afghan poppies destroyed, African holocaust, aged deaths, poppies more potent, Africa devastated, Africa in conflict, African aid threatened, aggressive weeds, Air France crash, air pockets, air pressure changes, airport farewells virtual, airport malaria, Agulhas current, Alaskan towns slowly destroyed, Al Qaeda and Taliban Being Helped, allergy increase, allergy season longer, alligators in the Thames, Alps melting, Amazon a desert, American dream end, amphibians breeding earlier (or not), anaphylactic reactions to bee stings, ancient forests dramatically changed, animals head for the hills, animals shrink, Antarctic grass flourishes, Antarctic ice grows, Antarctic ice shrinks, Antarctic sea life at risk, anxiety treatment, algal blooms, archaeological sites threatened, Arctic bogs melt, Arctic in bloom, Arctic ice free, Arctic ice melt faster, Arctic lakes disappear, Arctic tundra lost, Arctic warming (not), a rose by any other name smells of nothing, asteroid strike risk, asthma, Atlantic less salty, Atlantic more salty, atmospheric circulation modified, attack of the killer jellyfish, avalanches reduced, avalanches increased, Baghdad snow, Bahrain under water, bananas grow, barbarisation, bats decline, beer and bread prices to soar, beer better, beer worse, beetle infestation, beef shortage, bet for $10,000, big melt faster, billion dollar research projects, billion homeless, billions face risk, billions of deaths, bird loss accelerating, bird populations dying, bird strikes, bird visitors drop, birds confused, birds decline (Wales), birds driven north, birds face longer migrations, birds on long migrations threatened, birds return early, birds shrink(Aus), birds shrink (USA), bittern boom ends, blackbirds stop singing, blackbirds threatened, Black Hawk down, blizzards, blood contaminated, blue mussels return, borders redrawn, bluetongue, brains shrink, brewers droop, bridge collapse (Minneapolis), Britain one big city, Britain Siberian, Britain’s bananas, British monsoon, brothels struggle, brown Ireland, bubonic plague, Buddhist temple threatened, building collapse, building season extension, bushfires, butterflies move north, butterflies reeling, butterfly saved, carbon crimes, caribou decline, Cambodian sex trade fuelled, camel deaths, cancer, cancer deaths in England, cannibalism, cataracts, cats more amorous, caterpillar biomass shift, cave paintings threatened, chagas disease, childhood insomnia, children’s mental health, chocolate shortage, Cholera, circumcision in decline, cirrus disappearance, civil unrest, cloud increase, clownfish get lost, coast beauty spots lost, cockroach migration, cod go south, coffee threatened, coffee berry borer, coffee berry disease, cold climate creatures survive, cold spells, cold spells (Australia), colder waters (Long Island), cold wave (India), cold weather (world), cold winters, computer models, conferences, conflict, conflict with Russia, consumers foot the bill, coral bleaching, coral fish suffer, coral reefs dying, coral reefs grow, coral reefs shrink, coral reefs twilight, cost of trillions, cougar attacks, crabgrass menace, cradle of civilisation threatened, creatures move uphill, crime increase, crocodile sex, crocodiles driven from water, crops devastated, crop failures increase, cross-breeding, crumbling roads, buildings and sewage systems, cryptococcal disease, curriculum change, cyclones (Australia), damselflies forced back to UK, danger to kid’s health, Darfur, Dartford Warbler plague, daylight increase, deadly virus outbreaks, death rate increase (US), death rate drop, deaths to reach 6 million, decades of progress at risk, Dengue hemorrhagic fever, depression, desert advance, desert retreat, destruction of the environment, dig sites threatened, disasters, diseases move north, diving reefs closed, dog disease, dozen deadly diseases – or not, drought, ducks and geese decline, dust bowl in the corn belt, dust doubles, earlier pollen season, Earth axis tilt, Earth biodiversity crisis, Earth crumbling, Earth dying, Earth even hotter, Earth light dimming, Earth lopsided, Earth melting, Earth morbid fever, Earth on fast track, Earth past point of no return, Earth slowing down, Earth spins faster, Earth to explode, earth upside down, earthquakes, earthquakes redux, El Niño intensification, end of the world as we know it, erosion, emerging infections, encephalitis, English villages lost, equality threatened, Europe simultaneously baking and freezing, eutrophication, everyplace hit hardest, expansion of university climate groups, extinctions (apes, human, civilisation, koalas, lizards, logic, Inuit, smallest butterfly, cod, penguins, pikas, polar bears, possums, walrus, tigers, toads, turtles, pandas, penguins, plants, ladybirds, rhinoceros, salmon, trout, wild flowers, woodlice, a million species, half of all animal and plant species, mountain species, not polar bears, barrier reef, leaches, salamanders, tropical insects, flowers) experts muzzled, extreme changes to California, fading fall foliage, famine, farmers benefit, farmers go under, farm output boost, farming soil decline, fashion disaster, fever, figurehead sacked, fir cone bonanza, fires fanned in Nepal, fish bigger, fish catches drop, fish downsize, fish deaf, fish feminised, fish get lost, fish head north, fish lopsided, fish shrinking, fish stocks at risk, fish stocks decline, five million illnesses, flesh eating disease, flies on Everest, flood patterns change, floods, floods of beaches and cities, flood of migrants, flood preparation for crisis, flora dispersed, Florida economic decline, flowers in peril, flowers wilt, flying squirrels move up, fog increase in San Francisco, fog decrease in San Francisco, food poisoning, food prices rise, food prices soar, food production increased, food safety affected, food security threat (SA), football team migration, forest decline, forest expansion, foundations threatened, foundations increase grants, frog with extra heads, frosts, frostbite, frost damage increased, fungi fruitful, fungi invasion, fungi rot the world, games change, Garden of Eden wilts, geese decline in Hampshire, genetic changes, genetic diversity decline, gene pools slashed, geysers imperiled, giant icebergs (Australia), giant icebergs (Arctic), giant oysters invade, giant pythons invade, giant squid migrate, gingerbread houses collapse, glacial earthquakes, glacial retreat, glacier grows (California), glaciers on Snowden, glacier wrapped, global cooling, glowing clouds, golf course to drown, golf Masters wrecked, grain output drop (China), grain output stagnating (India), grandstanding, grasslands wetter, gravity shift, Great Barrier Reef 95% dead, great tits cope, greening of the North, Grey whales lose weight, Gulf Stream failure, habitat loss, haggis threatened, Hantavirus pulmonary syndrome, harvest increase, harvest shrinkage, hay fever epidemic, health affected, health of children harmed, health risks, health risks (even more), heart deaths, heart disease, heart attacks and strokes (Australia), heat waves, hedgehogs bald, hibernation affected, hibernation ends too soon, hibernation ends too late, homeless 50 million, hornets, human development faces unprecedented reversal, human fertility reduced, human health risk, human race oblivion, human rights violations, hurricanes, hurricane reduction, hurricanes fewer, hurricanes more intense, hurricanes not, hydropower problems, hyperthermia deaths, hyphthermia deaths, ice age, ice hockey extinct, ice sheet growth, ice sheet shrinkage, icebergs, ice sheet tipping point, illegal immigration, illness and death, inclement weather, India drowning, infrastructure failure (Canada), indigestion, industry threatened, infectious diseases, inflation in China, insect explosion, insect invasion, insurance premium rises, Inuit displacement, Inuit poisoned, Inuit suing, invasion of alien worms, invasion of Antarctic aliens, invasion of Asian carp, invasion of cane toads, invasion of caterpillars, invasion of cats, invasion of crabgrass, invasion of herons, invasion of jellyfish, invasion of king crabs, invasion of lampreys, invasion of midges, invasion of pine beetles, invasion of rats (China), invasion of slugs, island disappears, islands sinking, Italy robbed of pasta, itchier poison ivy, Japan’s cherry blossom threatened, jellyfish explosion, jets fall from sky, Kew Gardens taxed, kidney stones, killer cornflakes, killing us, kitten boom, koalas leaves inedible, koalas under threat, krill decline, lake empties, lake shrinking and growing, landslides, landslides of ice at 140 mph, large trees decline, lawsuits increase, lawsuit successful, lawyers’ income increased (surprise surprise!), lawyers want more, legionnaires’ surge, lives lost, lizards super intelligent, lives saved, lobsters grow, Loch Ness monster dead, locust plagues suppressed, low oxygen zones threaten sea life, lush growth in rain forests, Lyme disease, Major vegetation shifts, Malaria, Malaria decline, malnutrition, mammoth dung melt, mammoth ivory bonanza, manatees battle, mango harvest fails, Maple production advanced, Maple syrup shortage, marmots fatter, marine diseases, marine food chain decimated, Meaching (end of the world), Meat eating to stop, Mediterranean rises, megacryometeors, Melanoma, Melanoma decline, mental health decline, mental illness, methane emissions from plants, methane burps, methane runaway, melting permafrost, Mexican climate migrant flood, Middle Kingdom convulses, migration, migratory birds huge losses, microbes to decompose soil carbon more rapidly, milk production lost, minorities hit, monkeys at risk, monkeys on the move, Mont Blanc grows, monuments imperiled, moose dying, more bad air days, more research needed, mortality increased, mosquitoes adapting, mountain (Everest) shrinking, mountaineers fears, mountains break up, mountains green and flowering, mountains taller, mortality lower, Mubarak fall, murder rate increase, musk ox decline, Myanmar cyclone, narwhals at risk, narwhals suffocate, National Parks damaged, National security implications, native wildlife overwhelmed, natural disasters quadruple, neurological diseases, new islands, next ice age, NFL threatened, Nile delta damaged, noctilucent clouds, no effect in India, Northwest Passage opened, nuclear plants bloom, oaks dying, oaks move north, obesity, oblivion, ocean acidification, ocean acidification faster, ocean dead spots, ocean dead zones unleashed, ocean deserts expand, ocean salt extremes, ocean oxygen crisis, ocean waves speed up, Olympic Games to end, opera house to be destroyed, outdoor hockey threatened, owls turn brown, oxygen depletion zones, oyster herpes, ozone repair slowed, ozone rise, peat bogs problem, peat bogs no problem, penguin chicks frozen, penguin chicks smaller, penguins in the dark, penguin populations devastated, penguins replaced by jellyfish, penguins sex lives affected, personal carbon rationing, pest outbreaks, pests increase, pets in danger, phenology shifts, pines decline, pirate population decrease, pirates run rampant, plankton blooms, plankton plummeting, plankton wiped out, plants lose protein, plants march north, plants move uphill, polar bears aggressive, polar bears cannibalistic, polar bears deaf, polar bears drowning, polar bears fewer cubs, polar tours scrapped, pollination halved, porpoise astray, profits collapse, psychiatric illness, puffin decline, pushes poor women into prostitution, rabid bats, radars taken out, rail network threatened, railroad tracks deformed, rainfall increase, rainforest destruction, rape wave, refugees, reindeer endangered, reindeer larger, release of ancient frozen viruses, resorts disappear, respiratory diseases worsen, rice less fragrant, rice production fall, rice threatened, rice yields crash, rift on Capitol Hill, rioting and nuclear war, river flow impacted, river rerouted, rivers raised, road accidents, roads wear out, robins rampant, rocky peaks crack apart, roof of the world a desert, rooftop bars, Ross river disease, Russia under pressure, salinity reduction, salinity increase, Salmonella, salmon stronger, sardine run unpredictable, satellites accelerate, Schmallenberg virus, school closures, sea level rise, sea level rise faster, sea snot, seals mating more, seismic activity, sewer bills rise, severe thunderstorms, sex change, sexual dysfunction, sexual promiscuity, shark attacks, sharks booming, sharks hybridise, sharks moving north, sheep change colour, sheep shrink, shop closures, short-nosed dogs endangered, shrimp sex problems, shrinking ponds, shrinking sheep, shrinking shrine, Sidney Opera House wiped out, ski resorts threatened, slavery, skinks impacted, slow death, smaller brains, smog, snowfall decrease, snowfall increase, snowfall heavy, snow thicker, soaring food prices, societal collapse, soil change, soil subsidence, songbirds change eating habits, sour grapes, soybean crop to drop, space junk increase, space problem, spectacular orchids, spider danger in UK, spider bites to increase, spiders getting bigger, spiders invade Scotland, squid aggressive giants, squid larger, squid population explosion, squid tamed, squirrels reproduce earlier, starfish sperm eaten by parasites, stingray invasion, storm damage costs rise, storms wetter, stratospheric cooling, street crime to increase, subsidence, suicide, sunset displaced, swordfish in the Baltic, Tabasco tragedy, taxes, tea flavour change, tectonic plate movement, teenage prostitution, terrorists (India), thatched cottages at risk, threat to peace, ticks move northward (Sweden), tides rise, tigers eat people, tigers drown, tomatoes rot, tornado outbreak, tourism increase, toxic bacteria, toxic seaweed, trade barriers, trade winds weakened, traffic jams, transport snarl, transportation threatened, tree foliage increase (UK), tree growth slowed, tree growth faster, trees grow too fast, trees in trouble, trees less colourful, trees more colourful, trees lush, trees on Antarctica, treelines change, tropics expansion, tropopause raised, truffle shortage, truffles down, truffles increase, turtles crash, turtle feminised, turtles lay earlier, UFO sightings, UK coastal impact, UK Katrina, vampire bats, Venice flooded, volcanic eruptions, volcanoes awakened in Iceland, walnuts threatened, walrus pups orphaned, walrus stampede, walruses come ashore, wars over water, wars sparked, wars threaten billions, wasps, water bills double, water shortage to increase vegetarianism, wave of natural disasters, waves bigger, weather out of its mind, weather patterns awry, weather patterns last longer, Western aid cancelled out, West Nile fever, whale beachings, whales lose weight, whales move north, whales wiped out, wheat rust in Syria, wheat yields crushed in Australia, wild boars thrive, wildfires, wind shift, wind reduced, winds stronger, winds weaker, wine – Australian baked, , wine industry damage (California), wine industry disaster (US), wine – more English, wine – no more French , wine – England too hot, wine -German boon, wine passé (Napa), wine – Scotland best, wine stronger, winters in Britain colder, winter in Britain dead, witchcraft executions, wolverine decline, wolverines vanish, wolves eat more moose, wolves eat less, women cheat on vacation, workers laid off, World at war, World War 4, Yellow fever, zebra mussel threat, zoonotic diseases.

  2. John, that’s a great list, is it from your own creative writing, or is there a source somewhere?

    However, I take issue with your accusation that I’m being “cavalier”. I actually think it is quite cavalier to insinuate that “many deaths” have been caused by cancer from wind turbines, and many other claims made in prominent anti-wind websites.

  3. don’t forget the poverty induced health dilemmas from all the doctors that turbines have put out of work since more and more coal burning generators have been decommissioned.

  4. John Sullivan you tempt me to take a “personal” WTF to your your post. But I remind myself that a thoughtful, researched approach, delivered based on objective science will ultimately win out.
    If I may comment nevertheless: the post is ridiculous. Who is expected to wade through it without drowning in boredom? What is is your source? It looks like a cut & paste.

    And what is your point anyway?

  5. Chapman’s list is fair enough but the claims are so easily refuted that it doesn’t get us far. More insidious and harder to deal with are the claims of insomnia, anxiety, heart palpitations etc and it’s probably best not to pour scorn on those – merely point out that such symptoms are common in the community and the “causes” are many and various. An Age Insight article tracing the links between prominent Victorian political families( Baillieus, Wooldridges etc ) and the Landscape Guardians and the Waubra Foundation was very telling but unfortunately seems to have had little political impact.

  6. Wilma, I like your humane approach. The symptoms you point to are classicly coincident with depression. Having spoken with a number of WTS claimants I can attest that they felt disenfranchised / abandoned / alienated and were very likely depressed.

  7. I don’t propose to ridicule people who are sick, whatever the cause. But I do think the kind of sensationalising that goes on doesn’t help anyone, certainly not those who may be already anxious about their health.

    And much of this sensationalism seems to come from, or be amplified by, anti-windfarm campaigners who don’t themselves live near a turbine or have any complaints of noise and so on.

    And some of this sensationalising (many deaths? please) begs for ridicule. Has anyone looked at the statistics around lung cancer, asthma and so on in areas around coal mines and power stations?

    I’ve spoken to wind farm neighbours who find the noise very annoying. It’s a long jump from that annoyance to suggest that wind farms cause diabetes, for just one example, with no apparent evidence.

  8. So all the people i know who have up and left their homes around here are just making it up? its all in their heads is it? Has Simon Chapman been to visit any of them? done any studies on them? i know the answer to that.
    Go crawl back into your hole chapman

    1. Peter Masters could I ask you to read a brief bio on Professor Chapman. This one will give you some insight into the authority that Prof. Chapman brings to a debate. Please accept that when a person of authority takes a position (as Chapman has) he must take care not to risk that authority by publishing rubbish. That means carefully appraising the properly researched and even the improperly researched evidence before taking a position.

      See: http://sydney.edu.au/medicine/people/academics/profiles/simonchapman.php

      Whilst respecting your right to have a passionate opinion Peter, I think that on this occasion you may have mis-fired. If you know of people who have been left wind farm areas and their move might be linked to wind farms, see if you can initiate some investigation. But to date, many studies have found little or no evidence supporting the negative health externalities of wind farms. Maybe the area you are in has already been surveyed?

    2. Peter, do you live near Waubra? I’ve recently spoken with a couple of people there who are genuinely annoyed at times (and in one case, quite a lot) by the noise from the turbines. Noise annoyance is believable enough, but not very remarkable in that it happens from all sorts of sources and in many localities; and there are ways to deal with it. You can block the noise, you can help people become accustomed to it, if these don’t work there may be ways to reduce the amount of noise at the source; and so on.

      However the hysterical kinds of allegations made on some of the anti-wind sites (and by some irresponsible campaigners) really don’t help anyone to deal with these problems rationally; I expect they will if anything make the people who do suffer from noise (and who may be ill in other ways) less inclined to explore practical ways of dealing with the noise. Which benefits no-one, least of all the person actually complaining.

      1. Ben I have noticed a change in your attitude to those that are suffering from noise. This is seismic shift of your prior attitude. It is the reason that a buffer distance should be applied to industrial installations including holes in the ground

  9. I don’t think my attitude has changed. Noise is the one thing that I’ve always understood as a potential annoyance from wind farms. If I’ve said otherwise, please remind me where.

    The existing 40dB guidelines are more stringent than places like Germany, where there are a lot of turbines but not so many complaints, so I’m skeptical that we are going to find many people with noise issues (there appear to be only a very few with ongoing noise complaints at Waubra, for example).

    And in fact, the main reason for buffers from those “holes in the ground” would be the very harmful effects of fine particles of coal dust; noise is a much lesser worry than asthma, heart disease etc. which are the well documented effects of fine particulate pollution from coal.

    Which is why I find it quite “cavalier” (with the truth, among other things; to put it very mildly) to go around insinuating all these other terrible problems like cancer and diabetes are caused by turbines.

  10. What an absolutely hilarious list. I think Type 1 Diabetes and “eggs without yolks” are my favourites.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s